PLACEHOLDER BUILD. Rendered from sample fixture data (no
content API configured). Never publish to a live indexable page — set
PLUMBLINE_CONTENT_API_BASE + PLUMBLINE_SPACES_CDN_BASE
to build real content. (AUDIT-3 / AUDIT-4 placeholder-never-live.)
Water Heater Repair & Replacement [PLACEHOLDER] · the honest answer
Should I repair or replace my water heater?
The question every homeowner asks. Here's the rule Sean Driscoll [PLACEHOLDER] actually use on Newburgh-area jobs — and the real numbers behind it.
The honest rule
Under ~8 years and not leaking from the tank? Repair it. Over 12, leaking from the tank body, or rusty hot water? Replace it. [PLACEHOLDER copy]
Repair
$180
When it's the smart call
- Unit is newer and sound
- The fault is a part, not the body
- No repeated past failures
Replace · installed
$3k
When it's worth it
- Out of warranty or near end of life
- Failure is in the body, not a part
- Repeated repairs piling up
Read the fine print
What actually swings the price.
01
Access & location
A tight basement or upper-floor closet takes longer to reach and work than an open garage.
02
Venting & supply
Switching types can mean new venting or a line resize — often the biggest single swing.
03
Code upgrades
Older installs often need an added part to pass current code. We flag it up front.
04
Type & size
Capacity and fuel set the unit cost before labor.
Don't wait if…
When to call now vs. when it can wait.
Call now
- Water pooling where it shouldn't be
- No service with a houseful of people
- Any smell of gas (leave first, then call)
- Rusty or brown water
Can wait a day or two
- Performance slipping but still working
- A slow drip you can bucket
- A noise, but still running fine
- You're just planning ahead
Not sure which one you're looking at?
Tell Sean Driscoll [PLACEHOLDER] the age and the symptom and you'll get a straight answer — repair or replace — before quoting a dime.